Barefoot Bill's Island Grill

Located in the heart of St. Augustine, Florida, Barefoot Bill's Island Grill is a vibrant family-friendly hamburger restaurant that perfectly blends casual dining with a distinctive island-inspired flair. Whether you're craving a juicy, carefully crafted burger or fresh, flavorful seafood, this local gem offers a menu that invites you on a culinary journey infused with Caribbean zest and classic American comfort.

Dive into the menu where standout dishes like the Pirate Burger and the Calypso Burger reign supreme, each packed with layers of succulent, juicy beef and vibrant toppings that practically melt in your mouth. Reviewers rave about the Calypso Burger’s satisfying balance of richness and freshness—one guest described it as “oozing goodness” with every bite, a testament to the kitchen’s commitment to perfectly executed patties. For seafood enthusiasts, the Fish and Chips come golden crisp, paired with coleslaw that adds a refreshing crunch, while the Coconut Shrimp offers a tropical twist, its delicate breading and sweet flavors heightened by a tangy datil ranch dip. The Jamaican Chicken with its deeply jerk-seasoned, tender chicken breast and pepper jack cheese delivers a fiery kick, perfectly complemented by the cooling sides.

The dining atmosphere at Barefoot Bill’s Island Grill is effortless and welcoming, designed for comfortable, relaxed meals with family and friends. While it may have the inviting vibe of a casual bar, the genuine warmth of the staff truly elevates the experience—servers like Tamika and Demika have garnered heartfelt praise for their attentive, friendly service and their knack for making diners feel right at home. One customer fondly recalled how Tamika shared plenty of laughs during a challenging day, making their visit a memorable moment of comfort and connection.

Beyond burgers and shrimp, the menu's diversity caters to all tastes, featuring items like the savory Havana Pork Melt, the zesty Philly Cheesesteak, and the uniquely flavorful Lava Burger. Easily paired with refreshing beverages such as Caribe Pineapple Tropical Hard Cider or Kombucha, the offerings create a well-rounded dining experience. Families will appreciate the thoughtful kids' menu, with classic options like Chicken Strips and Grilled Cheese served at approachable prices.

What truly sets Barefoot Bill’s apart is its commitment to authenticity and community spirit. Diners often find themselves returning not just for the food, but for the genuine hospitality and lively island vibes. Whether it's your first visit or a welcome return, expect a meal that excites your palate and a staff who anticipates your needs before you even ask—making every visit feel personalized, relaxed, and absolutely satisfying.